New York’s Cooperative and Condominium Community
New York City
First Steps
"Boards should advise the old company that the new one will be in contact," says Paul Attinello, chief financial officer at Kaled Management, the man in charge of the company’s back office. "That way, the old company will be ready when I make contact asking for documentation, such things as an arrears list, the maintenance roll, secondary charges for parking, and tax returns for the corporation."
As a rule, there’s a high level of cooperation between outgoing and incoming management companies. "It’s a small industry," Attinello says. "We see a lot of the same players, so it’s usually a pretty cordial handshake. If we lose a building, I like to help out the new property manager. There’s no benefit to me to withhold information."
Most transitions are completed within 30 days, though some can take up to two months. As is the norm with many incoming management firms, Kaled doesn’t charge a new client for the first 30 days, even though the company is working on the account: "We’re working the building, we’re investing time into the account. We’re ramping up, putting information into our computer system. The way I see it, even though we aren’t getting paid, it’s a good investment for us."
Management Protocol
One reason it’s rare is that most management companies have an established protocol for transitions. "The key to a transition is having an organized list of the documents you need to obtain," says Michael Berenson, president of Akam Associates. "We have a very complete list — nearly 100 items. Then you have to make sure all contracts are reviewed, and make sure all contracted services are being provided. We find that many contracts are outdated. These older contracts, say for the elevators, might have 3 to 7 percent escalations each year. Over time they get priced out of the market. So we renegotiate and rebid those contracts."
Akam, one of the larger management companies in the city, has a "transition manager" on staff whose sole job is to handle the transfer of data when the company acquires or loses a management contract.
Boards can take solace in the fact that even if the company they’re letting go was lax about record-keeping, a competent management company can make order out of chaos. "When we take over management of a building, it’s usually because the previous company has gotten sloppy," says Lloyd Amster, chief executive officer of Prime Locations. "Records can be sloppy. But in order to get a building online, all we really need is a recent financial report, and we can start from there. We reconstruct everything, and we have a transition checklist. The first thing we check is that insurance is up to date. We check service contracts. We need to know if the building is in the middle of a major capital improvement project. We check the proprietary lease, and make sure that everyone who’s providing services has insurance in place. Then we send out a questionnaire to residents to update all contact information."
There are horror stories about documents getting lost in transition, and about tax bills or mortgage notices that don’t get transferred to the new management company in a timely fashion. "It can happen," says Peter Lehr, director of management at Kaled, "but we’ve got our checklist of which documents we have received. We know what to ask of our counterparts in the outgoing firm."
The top items that must be transferred: rent rolls, arrears list, tax ID number, copies of most recent bank statements, insurance policies (make sure they’re up to date), vendor contracts (laundry room, parking, elevator repair, etc.), the job file on any ongoing capital improvement project (including contractor and subcontractor contracts, architectural plans and specifications, engineer’s notes, and payment requisitions).
The transfer of data, while important, is only part of the transition equation. "When I take over a property, I do a walk-through," Lehr says. "I learn as much as I can from the super. I meet the staff and try to gauge their competency levels. Then I meet with the board and find their hot-button issues. We try to get as much information from them as we can."
Avoiding the Perils of Management Transition
There are two other transition scenarios, one fairly rare, the other increasingly common. The first is when a building goes from self-management to professional management; the second, usually found in new condo buildings, is when the sponsor/developer cedes the running of the building to a management company.
"The thing about a transition from self-management to professional management is that sometimes the level of expectation is very high," says Lehr. "The board should have high expectations, but they should be reasonable. We don’t have a crystal ball or magic dust. We have to go through the process. We’re not going to change things overnight."
With new condo construction returning to pre-recession levels, a much more common scenario is a condo board hiring a management company after the departure of the sponsor. It’s rarely smooth. "With transitions from sponsor/developers, we find that much of the information is not available and not handed over easily," say Berenson of Akam. "It’s unusual that you get all the documents in a comprehensive and timely fashion."
The problem is that usually there are no established processes — things like employee handbooks, a preventive maintenance schedule, alteration applications, and comprehensive applications for buyers.
In addition to establishing these processes, Akam puts together a five-year capital improvements and preventative maintenance plan and seeks to maximize income from ancillary sources, such as parking spaces. "We often find that the attention to detail was not in place," Berenson says. "The key thing is to improve service levels."
Adapted from "Smooth Transitions" by Bill Morris (Habitat, April 2015).
For more, see our Site Map or join our Archive >>
Engage, enrage, ask questions and give answers with your community of board members. Submit your questions and comments here!
Sign up for email newsletters, alerts, and digital e-news to stay informed about what’s happening in the co-op/condo community. A must for board directors, property managers, professionals and vendors!
Co-op and condo board business broken down into bite-sized bits – 2 stories each week. Read now on all digital devices.
Learn all the basics of NYC co-op and condo management, with straight talk from heavy hitters in the field of co-op or condo apartments
Professionals in some of the key fields of co-op and condo board governance and building management answer common questions in their areas of expertise
Got elected? Are you on your co-op/condo board?
Then don’t miss a beat! Stories you can use to make your building better, keep it out of trouble, save money, enhance market value, and make your board life a whole lot easier!
© 2023 The Carol Group, Ltd. All rights reserved
